Medicolegal Issues

Surgical Sponge Left After Hysterectomy

When "the thing speaks for itself," does the defense have a chance?

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

In January 2009, an Alabama woman with multiple sclerosis visited Dr T., the defendant ob-gyn, for severe pelvic pain. Dr T. made a diagnosis of a fibroid uterus and ovarian cysts. The patient underwent a transvaginal hysterectomy, but her pain persisted after the surgery.

After being discharged, she discovered a long strip of packing protruding from her vagina, which Dr T. instructed her to extract herself. After doing so, however, the patient continued to have pain, bleeding, and a foul–smelling vaginal discharge. Dr T. diagnosed urinary tract infection and bacterial vaginosis. Antibiotics and pain medication were prescribed, but the patient’s pelvic pain persisted.

In April 2009, Dr T. ordered CT to rule out an abscess or a foreign body. A gauze surgical sponge, left at the conclusion of the patient’s hysterectomy, was detected. Surgery was performed to remove the sponge.

The plaintiff alleged negligence in the sponge’s retention, maintaining that not only was a second surgery required, but that her multiple sclerosis was exacerbated as a result of the entire situation.

The defendant claimed that tests had been performed to investigate the possibility of a foreign body, and that as soon as the surgical sponge was detected, it was removed.

What was the outcome? >>

Pages

Recommended Reading

Audit: Children in Medicaid Missing Key Screenings
Clinician Reviews
HHS: Early Data Shows 9% Drop in HACs
Clinician Reviews
Pain Out of Proportion to a Fracture
Clinician Reviews
Feds Release Quality Data on Diabetes, Heart Disease, Infections
Clinician Reviews
Attorney: Be Prepared for Next Round of HIPAA Audits
Clinician Reviews
Giving Patients Ownership of Data Key to Solving Health IT Woes
Clinician Reviews
In Appendicitis Case, Patient Sues Clinic, Clinic Sues NP
Clinician Reviews
Going for the Gold
Clinician Reviews
DEA Schedule Change Inhibits Practice and Patient Care
Clinician Reviews
Pulmonary Embolism Ruled Out in Error
Clinician Reviews

Related Articles