Medicolegal Issues

When Wrong Test Is Ordered, “Wrongful Birth” Results

An ultrasound suggested fetal abnormality, but the incorrect follow-up DNA test was ordered. Here's how a controversial legal theory factored into the verdict.

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

At a New Jersey hospital, a pregnant woman underwent an ultrasound examination with results suggesting a possible fetal abnormality. In response, DNA testing of the patient and her husband was ordered to investigate for a suspected hormonal disorder. But the wrong test was ordered, and the results of that test were negative.

A baby girl was born with congenital adrenal hyperplasia, a condition causing ambiguous genitalia due to exposure to high concentrations of androgens in utero. She underwent genital reconstructive surgery at age 4 months and is expected to require additional surgery, lifelong hormone replacement therapy, and lifelong monitoring.

The parents claimed that they would have elected to terminate the pregnancy if they had been properly informed of the child’s condition.

What was the outcome? >>

Pages

Recommended Reading

Medical Management of Ectopic Pregnancy: Early Diagnosis is Key
Clinician Reviews
Calcium and Vitamin D Improve Metabolic Profile in Gestational Diabetes
Clinician Reviews
Preconception Health Care
Clinician Reviews
The High Cost of “Free Advice”
Clinician Reviews
Preconception Concerns: Diabetes and Pregnancy
Clinician Reviews
Suctioning Neonates at Birth: Time to Change Our Approach
Clinician Reviews
Case Studies in Toxicology: A Common Procedure, an Uncommon Complication
Clinician Reviews
US Preterm Birth Rate Falls to 17-Year Low
Clinician Reviews
Early Prediabetes Treatment Reduces HbA1C During Pregnancy
Clinician Reviews
Mind the Gap: Case Study in Toxicology
Clinician Reviews

Related Articles